STATE FACTS, NOT CONCLUSIONS
The magistrate must find reasonable grounds to believe that the facts alleged in the affidavit are true and the respondent probably meets the commitment criteria. Mere conclusions — such as "patient is dangerous" or "SI" — do not give the magistrate anything to evaluate. The affiant must assert specific, observable facts: signs, symptoms, behaviors, statements, and circumstances.
In re Ingram, 74 N.C. App. 579 (1985) — "Statute requires the affidavit to contain the facts on which the affiant's opinion is based. Mere conclusions do not suffice."| Conclusion (Will Get Dismissed) | Fact (What the Magistrate Needs) |
|---|---|
| "Violent" | "Hit boss with a wrench" |
| "Threatening" | "Said he would cut brother while he slept" |
| "Aggressive" | "Pushed Mom off the porch" |
| "Assaulted someone" | "Held hammer in air saying he was going to bust mother's head" |
| "Patient is mentally ill" | "Locks all her food in a cabinet because she says I'm trying to poison her" |
| "Respondent is dangerous" | "Constantly accuses me of trying to kill her" |
| "SI" | "Patient stated 'I want to hang myself with my bedsheet tonight'" |
| "Suicidal" | "Attempted to tie bedsheet around neck; found by staff and sheet removed" |
| "Bizarre behavior" | "Found lying disrobed in center of road in sub-freezing temperatures" |
| "Psychotic" | "Hearing voices telling him to hurt himself; sees shadows following him" |
Do not use words like "assaulted," "harassed," "battered," "stalked," or "threatened" in the petition. These are legal terms with specific statutory definitions — a magistrate or judge cannot accept them as established fact. Instead, describe exactly what happened:
| ❌ "Assaulted staff" | ✅ "Struck RN Smith with closed fist to the left side of her face" |
| ❌ "Harassed peers" | ✅ "Followed patient B into her room 4 times on 3/18, stood over her bed, and stated 'I'm watching you'" |
| ❌ "Threatened staff" | ✅ "Stated to MHT Jones: 'I will kill you when you come in my room tonight'" |
| ❌ "Battered another patient" | ✅ "Grabbed patient C by the hair and slammed his head into the wall on 3/19" |
Advice from a Buncombe County magistrate: use plain behavioral descriptions, not legal conclusions.
Click each card to expand details about each commitment pathway under NC law.
Inpatient — Mental Illness G.S. 122C-3 JFK Primary
Two requirements: Mentally ill and dangerous to self or others.
The petition must describe specific facts supporting both (1) mental illness and (2) dangerousness. Dangerousness has specific sub-criteria detailed in Sections 3 and 4 below.
Inpatient — Substance Abuse G.S. 122C-3
Two requirements: Substance abuser and dangerous to self or others.
Facts must establish both the substance use pattern and specific dangerous behaviors. Clinical shorthand like "intoxicated" is insufficient — describe what you observed.
Outpatient Commitment G.S. 122C-3
All four criteria must be met:
- Mentally ill
- Needs treatment to prevent further disability or deterioration that would predictably result in dangerousness
- Mental status/illness limits or negates ability to make an informed decision to seek or comply with treatment voluntarily
- Capable of surviving safely in the community with available supervision from family, friends, or others
This is a higher bar than inpatient — you must address all four prongs with facts.
Any one of these pathways, if supported by sufficient facts, can establish danger to self. Click each to expand.
1 Inability to Self-Care + Probability of Debilitation
Prong 1: Unable to exercise self-control, judgment, or discretion in conducting daily responsibilities and social relations; unable to satisfy needs for nourishment, medical care, shelter, self-protection, and safety.
Prong 2: Reasonable probability of serious physical debilitation in the near future without treatment.
- "Patient has refused all food for [X] days"
- "Patient has not bathed or changed clothing in [X] days"
- "Patient is unable to identify current date, location, or own name"
- "Patient wandered into traffic on [date]"
- "Prior hospitalization on [date] for dehydration/malnourishment following similar episode of medication non-compliance"
2 Suicide — Attempted or Threatened
Attempted or threatened suicide and reasonable probability of suicide without treatment.
- "Patient stated 'I am going to kill myself by [method] when I get the chance'"
- "Patient attempted to [specific action] on [date/time]"
- "Patient was found [specific circumstance — e.g., tying ligature]"
- "Patient has [X] prior suicide attempts, most recently on [date] by [method]"
3 Self-Mutilation
Attempted or engaged in self-mutilation and reasonable probability of serious repetition without treatment.
- "Patient cut [body part] with [object] on [date]"
- "Patient was found banging head repeatedly against wall causing visible [injury]"
- "Patient has [X] documented episodes of self-harm in past [timeframe]"
Any one of these pathways, if supported by sufficient facts, can establish danger to others.
1 Bodily Harm — Inflicted, Attempted, or Threatened
Inflicted, attempted, or threatened serious bodily harm and reasonable probability of repetition.
- "Patient struck [staff/patient] with [object/fist] on [date] causing [injury]"
- "Patient stated 'I will kill [person] when I leave here' on [date]"
- "Patient charged at [person] and had to be physically restrained on [date]"
2 Substantial Risk of Serious Bodily Harm
Created substantial risk of serious bodily harm to another person and reasonable probability of repetition.
- "Patient threw [heavy object] at [person] on [date], narrowly missing their head"
- "Patient set fire to [location] on [date]"
3 Extreme Property Destruction
Engaged in extreme destruction of property and reasonable probability of repetition.
- "Patient destroyed [specific items] in their room on [date]"
- "Patient smashed [specific property] causing $[amount] in damage on [date]"
What Counts as the "Relevant Past"?
Acts must be within the "relevant past" — close enough to the present to have probative value on whether the conduct will continue. Acts that are part of or connected to the current or ongoing episode, incident, or situation qualify.
Previous episodes of dangerousness may be considered when assessing the probability of future harm — especially when they show a pattern connected to the current situation (e.g., prior medication non-compliance leading to the same type of dangerous behavior).
NC DHHS provides free video training modules for commitment examiners. These are an excellent refresher for anyone who may need to complete an IVC petition.
Contact: IVCCommunication@dhhs.nc.gov (Tanya Thacker) for CE certification questions
IVC Petition — Facts Section Reference
JFK ADATC — Buncombe County, NC • Generated from IVC Petition Writing Guide